Remember me
A former teacher was today fined £500 and told he had shown 'total disrespect' to those who had fought and died for their country by gatecrashing a Remembrance Sunday event in a fake admiral uniform.
Jonathan Carley, 65, sparked fury after laying a wreath at the ceremony in Llandudno, North Wales dressed in a Rear Admiral's uniform with 12 medals pinned to his jacket.
He saluted and then marched off to take his place next to VIPs including the mayor during the event honouring Britain's fallen heroes on November 9.
Among his array of medals were the prestigious Distinguished Service Order (DSO) and the Queen's Volunteer Reserves Medal, which is only given to military reservists.
But the combination led online sleuths to question his legitimacy - because no single serviceperson is believed to have been bestowed with both.
Carley was later arrested at his home 40 miles away in Harlech, Gwynedd, telling police: 'I've been expecting you.'
It emerged that he had altered a naval uniform issued to him while leading a group of cadets, hiring a tailor to sew admiral's rings onto the sleeves, and buying the medals online.
In reality he had never been in the Royal Navy or served at sea, a court heard today, and had donned the fake uniform because he 'sought a sense of belonging or affirmation'.
Jonathan Carley, 65, arrived at court today charged with wearing military uniform without permission
Alleged 'fake' admiral Jonathan Carley, 65, centre, who has been charged after gatecrashing a Remembrance Sunday event
Pictured left to right: A Distinguished Service Order Medal and The Queen's Volunteer Reserves Medal
Carley was subsequently charged with wearing uniform or dress bearing the mark of His Majesty's forces without permission.
The offence - which dates back to 1894 - carries a maximum sentence of a £1,000.
Today Carley - dressed smartly in civilian clothes - appeared in the dock at Llandudno Magistrates Court where he pleaded guilty.
Fining him £500, District Judge Gwyn Jones told Carley that it was a 'sad reflection' on him that he had chosen to target such a solemn day of remembrance.
‘It should have been a genuine opportunity to remember and to think about the lives of all those who have served the country and their community, with so many people not being able to be there,' he told him.
‘You were there not as a genuine person but as someone who came to deceive and create a falsehood.
‘Your actions totally disrespect the memories of all those persons who have fallen and causes a great deal of pain to families.’
Earlier prosecutor James Neary said Carley - who had never previously been in court - had posed as an admiral because he 'sought a sense of belonging or affirmation'.
It was accepted that Carley had not sought to disrupt the day's solemn proceedings, he added - but that when he was unmasked as an imposter it had provoked outrage.
The Daily Mail previously revealed that Carley has donned the same fake admiral costume in two other Remembrance Sunday services in Caernarfon - once in 2018 and again in 2019.
Join the debate
What should be the punishment for people who fake military service at national events?
Jonathan Carley, 65, arriving at court today where he was fined £500 after pleading guilty to wearing uniform or dress bearing the mark of His Majesty's forces without permission
Pictured: Jonathan Carley (centre) at a Remembrance Sunday service in 2018
Medals he was wearing included awards for service in Syria and Iraq, the court heard, as well as one issued by NATO and another marking Queen Elizabeth II’s golden jubilee.
He identified himself to parade marshals as a rear admiral representing the Lord Lieutenant of Clwyd, Mr Neary said.
Carley’s medals and ‘distinguished’ appearance meant they took him at his word, he added.
But soon after the parade, photographs of Carley dressed as an admiral ‘went viral’, the prosecutor said, with online researchers branding him a fake, and he was reported to police.
Arrested days later at his home in nearby seaside castle town of Harlech, Carley – who was described as ‘remorseful’ - told police: ‘I’ve been expecting you.’
Both the uniform and medals were found in his car – Carley claimed he was about to ‘surrender’ them.
Instead they were taken away and destroyed.
Carley was also ordered to pay £85 prosecution costs and a £200 surcharge.
Earlier Mark Haslam, defending, said it was a ‘very sad case’.
He said: ‘He wanted to be a part of the proceedings. He wanted to play a part.
'He accepts through me that his way of playing a part was totally inappropriate.’
He said Carley, a man of previous good character, was ‘extremely respectful’ during the course of the ceremony.
He ‘seriously underestimated’ the anxiety, anger and distress his actions would cause and had since been ‘publicly humiliated’, he added.
Leaving court, Carley did not answer questions from reporters but stood next to Mr Haslam as he delivered a short statement.
Mr Haslam said: ‘My client would like to reiterate his apologies to all of those who have been affected by what he did.
‘As we made clear in court, he is utterly remorseful and he accepts the sentence of the court.’
The Walter Mitty Hunters Club, a group dedicated to unearthing cases of 'stolen valour', say records indicate no-one has earned both the DSO and QVRM.
Carley is only mentioned once in the London Gazette, the official record for military listing.
Jonathan Carley (centre) at another war memorial service wearing a rear admiral outfit in 2019
However, he is listed as a 2nd Lieutenant on probation with the combined cadet force Cheltenham College, where he was a history teacher.
He has also previously said he studied at Christ Church, Oxford, as well as a business degree at Harvard.
In a newspaper article he said he had been a boat captain at Oxford and had rowed at the top US university.
'As a schoolmaster, he coached at Eton and Cheltenham before moving to Shiplake,' the article read.
Carley is understood to have been a history and politics teacher at Cheltenham college in 1988.
After the parade, a Llandudno council spokesman said: 'The Town Council was not aware of, or notified of, the gentleman’s attendance in advance. He appeared on the day.
'He was approached by the Parade Marshall and identified himself as a Rear Admiral and that he was representing the Lord Lieutenant's Office.
'The Council would like to add that it would not wish this to overshadow what was an excellent parade and remembrance service, and that with the exception of the identity of the gentleman he laid his wreath respectfully before leaving.
'The Council understands that military organisations are looking into this, and we are awaiting any response.'
A Lord Lieutenant of Clwyd spokesman said: 'The Lord Lieutenant had no knowledge of asking anyone to go to the event on his behalf.
'The council sent over a photograph of the man but nobody here recognised him. The matter is under investigation at the moment.'
A Royal Navy spokesman said: 'Impersonating a Naval officer is insulting to anyone connected to the service and could be considered a criminal offence.
'Nothing should detract from the poignancy of Remembrance Sunday which can be a sombre time for members of the Royal Navy family and an opportunity for people in communities across the United Kingdom to pay their respects to people who have served or are serving their country.'
Comments (0)